Compliance with Biodiversity Requirements in the Nahmint Watershed


Investigation finds old growth, biodiversity at risk near Port Alberni

VICTORIA – An investigation of a complaint about BC Timber Sales’ (BCTS) logging of large old growth trees in the Nahmint River Watershed has found that BCTS’s forest stewardship plan (FSP) is not consistent with the Vancouver Island Higher Level Plan Order and does not adequately protect old forest and biodiversity values in some ecosystems.

“The 2001 Vancouver Island Land Use Plan Order sets specific objectives for conserving biodiversity,” said Kevin Kriese, chair, Forest Practices Board. “More detailed landscape unit planning was supposed to provide clear direction on how much and where to conserve old and mature forest, but that planning was never completed. BCTS was left with a complicated set of legal objectives to interpret, and we found it missed important details that are required to manage for biodiversity in the Nahmint.”

In its FSP, BCTS commits to conserving a minimum amount of old forests in biogeoclimatic zone variants, but the Vancouver Island Land Use Plan Order requires it to conserve old forest in each site series – a finer scale of classification that captures a wider range of the diversity of the ecosystems found in the area.

“BCTS’s FSP did not meet the legal objective, and it should not have been approved. We looked at the remaining forest in the watershed and found there are some ecosystems that could be at risk if more logging takes place in them,” Kriese said.

The report recommends that government complete landscape unit planning to specify the amounts of forest to retain in different site series and that BCTS amend its FSP to achieve the legal objectives. It also recommends BCTS ensure it does not sell any timber sales in these highrisk ecosystems until a landscape unit plan is completed.

The complaint was triggered when Ancient Forest Alliance members saw BCTS licensees harvesting large old trees in 2018. They also raised concerns about the adequacy of a government investigation of the matter. The board found that government’s investigation was reasonable. However, the current legislation limits the ability to enforce the provisions of the Vancouver Island Higher Level Plan Order.

“The current legal framework does not permit government to ensure that FSPs approved in error can be amended, and this does not give the public confidence in government’s compliance and enforcement,” Kriese said. “We are recommending government fix this gap in the legislation.”

The Nahmint River Watershed is about 20 kilometres southwest of Port Alberni and covers 19,950 hectares. It begins at Alberni Inlet and extends northwest, surrounding the Nahmint River and Nahmint Lake. It is within the traditional territory of the Nuu-chah-nulth people.

The Forest Practices Board is B.C.’s independent watchdog for sound forest and range practices, reporting its findings and recommendations directly to the public and government. The board investigates public complaints about forest and range practices on public lands and appropriateness of  government enforcement. It can also make recommendations for improvement to practices and legislation.



Darlene Oman
Forest Practices Board
250 213-4705 / 1 800 994-5899

May 12, 2021

Download Report

Natural Resource Region

West Coast


South Island

Other Related Documents

Response to Recommendations